5. Revisions and Later Editions Examples (2)

Change in Name Order of Collaborating Authors

Source: LC Training Special Topics Revised Editions of Monographs:  Slide 15. In the examples, relationship designators added to the creator AAPs (PCC practice not followed by LC).

Note that both editions are cataloged under RDA.

RDA “6.27.1.3: if there is no consistency in the order in which the persons are named in resources embodying the work or in reference sources, construct the authorized access point based on the first resource received,” which is normally the earlier edition.

100 1   ‡a Burton, Larry W., ‡e author.
245 1 4 ‡a The language of argument / ‡c Larry W. Burton, Daniel McDonald.
250     ‡a First edition.

Order of author’s names flipped between editions.

100 1   ‡a Burton, Larry W., ‡e author.
245 1 4 ‡a The language of argument / ‡c Larry W. Burton, Daniel McDonald.
250     ‡a Second edition.

Additional Collaborator

Source: LC Training Special Topics Revised Editions of Monographs:  Slide 17

100 1   ‡a McLean, Andrew James, ‡e author.
245 1 0 ‡a Investing in real estate / ‡c Andrew James McLean.

Presenter notes: It seems reasonable to think that when a creator is joined by an additional collaborator, [the resource] could be considered a new expression rather than a new work (unless you are given information that it has very different scope/content).  Note, in this case, if you determined that the differences were so vast that the collaboration really represented a new work, you would have to break the conflict between works.

100 1   ‡a McLean, Andrew James, ‡e author.
245 1 0 ‡a Investing in real estate / ‡c Andrew James McLean and Gary Eldred. <co-authors also true for Second-Fifth editions>
250     ‡a Second edition.

Original Author Dropped

Source: PCC Relationship Designators TG Rpt, Appendix D

100 1   ‡a O’Brien, John, ‡c LL.M., ‡e author.
245 1 0 ‡a Conflict of laws / ‡c John O’Brien.
250     ‡a Second edition.
264   1 ‡a London : ‡b Cavendish, ‡c 1999.
700 1   ‡i Based on (work): ‡a Smith, Raymond, ‡d -19995. ‡t Conflict of laws.

Linking RDA to a “Rule of 3” AACR2

Source:  LC Training Special Topics Revised Editions of Monographs:  Slide 20

Example 1. AACR2 original; entry under title because of “rule of three”

245 0 0 ‡a Veterinary microbiology and microbial disease / ‡c P.J. Quinn … [et al.].

Example 2.  RDA record. Presenter suggestion:

  • Follow RDA for naming the work in bib record

  • Don’t use 130/240 or 7XX related work

  • Optionally, use unstructured/structured description to relate the expressions (500 or 775) -Helps the user to find, identify, select

Structured description (775 rather than 500):

100 1   ‡a Quinn, P. J., ‡e author.
245 1 0 ‡a Veterinary microbiology and microbial disease / ‡c P.J. Quinn, B.K. Markey, F.C. Leonard, E.S. FitzPatrick, S. Fanning, P.J. Hartigan.
250     ‡a Second edition.
264   1 ‡a London : ‡b Cavendish, ‡c 1999.
775 0 8 ‡i Revision of (expression): ‡t Veterinary microbiology and microbial disease ‡d Oxford ; Ames, Iowa : Blackwell Science, 2002